CheyenneOct 26, 2025
The real Parm sprinkled on top really sets these wings over the edge!
sauce: Garlic parm
HOT TAKE 6/10WingScore 6.8/10
mixedordered medium / tasted mediumbone-insaucygarlic parm
6.8/10
The room's Hot Takes and the five-part rubric mostly agree. The headline weighs all 2 check-ins, with less certainty until the crowd grows.
See how WingScore worksThe real Parm sprinkled on top really sets these wings over the edge!
sauce: Garlic parm
The unofficial Bills bar of Cincy, great sauces and other Buffalo foods as well like pizza logs and beef on weck.
sauce: Garlic-Parm
The badge is free, live, and links back to this spot's page. It shows the community score — scores are never for sale and a badge never changes one.
<a href="https://www.cafowings.com/restaurants/2f2a40db-71a3-43ec-96d9-a6a40a5b4c89-the-pony-cincinnati-oh?utm_source=badge&utm_medium=embed"><img src="https://www.cafowings.com/api/badge/2f2a40db-71a3-43ec-96d9-a6a40a5b4c89" alt="CAFO WingScore for The Pony" width="240" height="56"></a>